I need an essay (1250-1500 words) that puts these two ideas into competition, ul

I need an essay (1250-1500 words) that puts these two ideas into competition, ultimately arguing that one of these ideas is more precedent/is better…
1) how Edward’s repeated losses lead Edward to learn to feel and reciprocate love.
2) how Edward’s repeated experiences of being loved and cared for lead Edward to learn to feel and reciprocate love.
It doesn’t matter which idea wins, just as long as the thesis is arguable and focused; the essay should be more analysis and less summary of the novel.