Watch a film of your choice and critique two scenes using two elements of film grammar we’ve learned this semester. Does the film work? A mixed success? A failure? You may explain how the film has inventive camerawork but suffers as a story, for example; or you might praise the costumes but give thumbs down to the acting. The requirements:

You may not use an MCU or DC adaptation or any comic book or graphic novel adaptation. Too easy!
Your film must have been made before 2010.

Prove your points by citing your film. Be sure to name the personnel (director, cinematographer, visual designer, etc.) when relevant.

Your reflection must be 1-2 pages long. Do not use terms like “I believe,” “personally,” “I think,” “I feel.” Do not use first person. Don’t evaluate these films (“Night of the Living Dead is a hilarious film”). Avoid a casual, chatty, gossipy tone.

Finally, your abstracts should mention in the first sentence what arguments you’ll make about your film.

Struggling with where to start this assignment? Follow this guide to tackle your assignment easily!

Writing a strong film critique requires a clear structure, precise arguments, and a formal tone. Follow this step-by-step guide to ensure your paper meets the assignment’s requirements and stands out.

Step 1: Choose an Appropriate Film

Select a film made before 2010 that is not an MCU, DC, or comic/graphic novel adaptation.
Pick a film with strong technical elements that you can analyze critically.

Step 2: Watch the Film and Take Notes

Focus on two specific scenes.
Identify two film grammar elements (e.g., cinematography, mise-en-scène, editing, lighting, sound design).
Take notes on key moments that support your critique.

Step 3: Develop a Clear Thesis Statement

Your first sentence should summarize your argument about the film’s success, mixed success, or failure.
Example: While the film’s cinematography is inventive, its weak character development hinders its effectiveness.

Step 4: Structure Your Paper

Introduction (1 Paragraph)

Introduce the film (title, director, year of release).
Present your thesis statement.
Mention the two film grammar elements you will analyze.

Body Paragraph 1: First Scene Analysis

Briefly describe the scene.
Explain how the first film grammar element is used (e.g., “The cinematography in this scene creates tension through handheld camera movements.”).
Cite relevant film personnel (director, cinematographer, etc.).
Analyze how this technique impacts the film’s overall effectiveness.

Body Paragraph 2: Second Scene Analysis

Describe the second scene.
Analyze the second film grammar element (e.g., “The lighting in this sequence enhances the film’s dramatic tone.”).
Cite key personnel involved.
Connect this analysis to your thesis.

Conclusion (1 Paragraph)

Summarize your key points.
Reinforce your overall evaluation of the film (success, mixed success, or failure).
End with a strong closing statement.

Step 5: Follow the Writing Guidelines

Write in third person (avoid “I believe,” “I think,” “I feel”).
Use a formal tone (avoid casual or chatty language).
Provide specific examples and citations.
Keep your reflection 1-2 pages long.

By following these steps, you’ll craft a well-structured, analytical critique that meets the assignment’s expectations!

Analyzing Film Scenes: A Structured Approach to Critique