* Summarize the research question for the study and evaluate whether it is clear

* Summarize the research question for the study and evaluate whether it is clearly stated and appropriate for a qualitative research study.
* Analyze the literature review section of the paper and evaluate whether the authors provide sufficient background and context for the research question.
* Evaluate whether the authors effectively use the literature to situate the study within the broader academic field.
* Identify the qualitative research design/methodology used (e.g., case study, ethnography, phenomenological study, grounded theory study, content analysis, or thematic analysis) and discuss the appropriateness of the design in the identified case.
* Critique the strengths and limitations of the research design and suggest possible improvements or alternative approaches.